There are detailed frameworks for managing API evolution, one of the most challenging aspects of treating APIs as products, with three primary strategies outlined:
Global Versioning
Entire API versions (v1, v2) that provide clear upgrade paths but increase operational complexity.
Evolution-Only Approach
Continuous backward-compatible improvements without versioning, following strict extension rules:
- Never remove anything
- Never change processing rules
- Never make optional things required
- Anything added must be optional
Hybrid Model
Combining evolution for non-breaking changes with versioning for breaking changes: the approach used by companies like Stripe.
RESTful API Design Patterns and Best Practices highlights a MagicStore case study that demonstrates this in practice. When replacing their confusing /catalog endpoint with /products, the team didn't force immediate migration. Instead, they:
- Introduced /products alongside existing /catalog
- Added deprecation headers: Sunset: Wed, 30 Sep 2025 23:59:59 GMT
- Provided comprehensive migration guides
- Monitored usage analytics to track transition progress
- Only removed /catalog after ensuring complete migration
This disciplined approach transformed a potentially disruptive breaking change into a trust-building demonstration of thoughtful stewardship.